Friday, July 9, 2010

Dreyfus the Martyr.

On the outside looking in, the Dreyfus Affair seems to be not only incredibly arbitrary, but a direct insult to an entire ethic/religious group. That being said, in one looks deep into the subject, it becomes apparent that this chain of events, however unfortunate, may have been the needed catalyst for the formation of a Jewish state. The Dreyfus Affair occurred in 1894, when Jewish French officer Alfred Dreyfus was wrongly accused of spying/treason (supplying important military information to Germany). Dreyfus was convicted and sent to Devils Island. In 1898, When Emile Zola published his article accusing the French government of wrongfully accusing Dreyfus on the sole basis that he was Jewish (there was no physical evidence that it was Dreyfus and actually more evidence exonerating him). This stirred up a lot of tension in France and across Europe and effectively created a division between the French people. I believe this is important because I feel these events partly inspired sentiment for a Jewish state. It is seen in the actions of a young man covering the trial named Theodore Herzl. Herzl is widely regarded as the father of Zionism. Zionism was the movement, that Herzl was able to really galvanize in the late 19th century, that aimed for the establishment of a Jewish sate (in the land between Jordan, Egypt, Syria, and the Mediterranean Sea, then known as Palestine). Herzl, a Austro-Hungarian Jew, was inspired while a journalist on the Dreyfus trial to really intensify this movement, which would ultimately culminate with the 1948 establishment of a Jewish state in Israel. I found it quite interesting to see just a small part in the much larger history of the Jewish people. Its great to see how a singular event like the Dreyfus Affair could join together an entire people.

4 comments:

  1. The Dreyfus Affair is a very interesting event. Until I read an article in the New Yorker about it last year, I never really had any idea of what is was all about. If you just heard the basic details of what occurred, you would never think that it would have such wide-ranging consequences: a single officer is demoted because of suspicion of spying. But I guess it was a case of many different social movements or energies coming to a head in one event. As for Hertzl, it really goes to show the power of ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  2. As a French student, this isn't the first time that I have studied the Dreyfus affair, and the interesting thing is that we hardly touched the tip of the iceberg concerning the kind of unrest that the affair created in France, particularly in Paris. In a France where this was not entirely safe, people would assemble, protest and form all sorts of public spectacles in protest. While this is an example of the antisemtitism of the time, it also shows that not everyone shared the sentiment; there were many who were more concerned about justice than they were about Dreyfus' religion/ethnicity.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is hard to realize the impact of specific events when covering the material at such a rapid pace, thanks for the deeper perspective. The Dreyfus Affair showed the attitudes of many in Europe at the time, putting religion aside; people were struggling to come to a consensus on any issue. Tensions were mounting on every facet of society and it forced people to be polarized on so many issues, it seems as though Dreyfus came along and made people put themselves into a category on yet another issue.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The Dreyfus Affair in many ways was THE defining event of the French Third Republic and it highlighted and laid bare the great divisions in French society. Although seeming to revolve solely around one man, the Affair pointed to larger questions of what type of state France would be and who would guide and control France. Outside of France, it indicated a growing anti-Semitism and belied the security some Jews felt as result of 19th century emancipation and their greater ability to assimilate in society. An interesting perspective on the Affair's impact on Herzl can be found in Carl Schorske's Fin-de-Siecle Vienna.

    ReplyDelete